
Nintendo Mario & Luigi: Brothership
Specifications
Compare Prices
Found 1 storeAbout Our Prices: Prices are updated regularly and may include affiliate commissions. Amazon links use our affiliate program to support the site.
Pros & Cons
What We Love
- Gorgeous cel-shaded visuals with excellent character animations
- Engaging combat system with creative new special moves
- Distinct and varied island environments to explore
- Strong soundtrack mixing classic themes with sea shanty elements
- Improved character development for Luigi
Areas for Improvement
- Significant performance issues in busy scenes
Our Review
The visual design of Brothership represents a significant evolution for the series, with vibrant cel-shaded graphics that pop on the Switch's screen. Character animations are fluid and expressive, bringing personality to every interaction. The nautical theme is cleverly integrated into both the environmental design and user interface elements, with each island featuring distinct visual motifs that range from tropical paradises to mechanical wonderlands.
Performance-wise, the game maintains the series' signature timing-based combat system while introducing new nautical-themed special moves. However, frame rate issues occasionally disrupt the precise timing needed for combat, particularly during more elaborate attack animations. The game runs at a targeted 60fps but frequently drops frames in busy areas or during complex battle sequences.
The user experience retains the dual-character control scheme the series is known for, with each brother mapped to different buttons. The new ship navigation mechanics add an interesting layer to exploration, though the constant need to dock and undock when visiting islands can become tedious. The menu system is clean and intuitive, but excessive tutorial prompts and dialogue boxes frequently interrupt the flow of gameplay.
From a value perspective, Brothership offers substantial content with its roughly 30-hour campaign. The variety of islands to explore and side quests to complete provides plenty of entertainment, though much of it feels like padding rather than meaningful content. While the game introduces several new mechanics and features, it doesn't quite justify its premium price point when compared to other recent Mario RPG releases.
Our Conclusion
🏁Final Verdict
Good ChoiceMario & Luigi: Brothership marks a long-awaited but ultimately mixed return for the beloved RPG series. While the game features stunning visuals and engaging combat mechanics, it suffers from pacing issues and excessive padding that bog down the experience. The nautical theme and island-hopping adventure provide a fresh setting, but the charm of earlier entries feels somewhat diluted by overwrought dialogue and tedious fetch quests.
Mario & Luigi: Brothership demonstrates both the potential and limitations of modernizing this beloved series. While the core combat mechanics and visual presentation show genuine evolution, the game's structural issues and technical shortcomings prevent it from reaching the heights of its predecessors. Despite these flaws, there's still enough charm and engaging gameplay to satisfy series fans, even if newcomers might find the experience somewhat bloated and uneven.
Buying Guide
Key Considerations
- •Time investment for lengthy campaign
- •Tolerance for frequent dialogue and tutorials
- •Comfort with timing-based combat mechanics
- •Interest in exploration-heavy gameplay
Best For
- •Longtime Mario & Luigi series fans
- •Players who enjoy character-driven RPGs
- •Those who appreciate timing-based combat systems
- •Completionists who enjoy collecting and side quests
Skip If
- •You prefer faster-paced action games
- •You have limited patience for lengthy dialogue
- •You're sensitive to frame rate inconsistencies
- •You dislike backtracking and fetch quests